Articles Posted in Criminal defense

by

Why Remaining Silent in Chicago Is Your Right—Not a Crime

In neighborhoods all over Chicago—whether it’s Albany Park, Hyde Park, or South Shore—people interact with police officers every day. These encounters often begin casually but can quickly escalate into tense, high-pressure situations where you’re expected to talk. Many people believe that refusing to answer police questions could get them charged with a crime like obstruction. But under Illinois law, that’s not how it works.

You have a constitutional right to remain silent when questioned by law enforcement. The Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution and Article I, Section 10 of the Illinois Constitution both protect your right against self-incrimination. As a long-time Chicago criminal defense lawyer, I can tell you that this right is not conditional. You don’t have to wait to be arrested, and you don’t have to wait for a lawyer to be present. You can assert your right to remain silent at any time during a police interaction.

Continue reading

by

How Innocent Conversations Turn Into Criminal Cases in Chicago

In Chicago, some of the most damaging criminal cases don’t begin with an arrest. They begin with a conversation. A detective calls and says they want to ask a few questions. An officer stops by your home and says they are “just gathering information.” A federal agent tells you that you are “not a suspect” and that they are only trying to understand what happened. Those words are often carefully chosen, and they are rarely said for your benefit.

As a Chicago criminal defense lawyer, I’ve seen this pattern repeat itself for decades. People who genuinely believe they have nothing to hide agree to talk. They assume honesty will protect them. Instead, their statements become the foundation of a criminal charge weeks or even months later. By the time they call a lawyer, the damage is already done.

Continue reading

by

Can Law Enforcement Question You Without Arresting You?

This is a question I’ve answered hundreds of times over the years: Can police—or federal agents—question me at my job or home if I haven’t been arrested? In Chicago, the answer is yes, they can. But just because they can, doesn’t mean you have to answer them.

It’s common for people in the Chicago area to get approached by CPD detectives, FBI agents, or other investigators without warning. These encounters often happen at work, outside your house, or even inside your home if you allow them in. The officers may act polite, friendly, and make the conversation feel informal. But understand this: you may already be under investigation, and the goal of that “friendly conversation” is often to gather evidence before you lawyer up.

Continue reading

by

Knowing When Silence is Smarter Than Speaking

Chicago police make traffic stops every day. Sometimes it’s for speeding on Lake Shore Drive, other times it’s rolling through a stop sign in Pilsen. For many drivers, that brief encounter with an officer feels routine—until it isn’t. When flashing lights appear in the rearview mirror, people often forget they still have rights. One of the most misunderstood of these rights is the right to remain silent. The question I get all the time is: “Do I have to talk to the officer?”

As a Chicago criminal defense lawyer, I tell clients that what you say during a stop can change the entire outcome of your case. Most people don’t realize how much legal damage they do by trying to talk their way out of trouble. The simple truth is, aside from handing over your driver’s license, proof of insurance, and vehicle registration, you don’t have to say a word. And in many situations, saying nothing is exactly what protects you the most.

Continue reading

by

The Truth About Saying “No” to a Vehicle Search During a Traffic Stop in Chicago

If you’ve ever been pulled over by police in Chicago, you may have found yourself in an uncomfortable position—facing a uniformed officer asking, “Mind if I search your car?” In that moment, many drivers say yes without really thinking it through. Maybe they don’t want to seem confrontational. Maybe they think refusing will make them look guilty. Or maybe they didn’t know they had the right to say no.

As a Chicago criminal defense attorney, I’ve represented countless clients who were charged with crimes after a traffic stop led to a car search. What most of them had in common is that they gave police permission—knowingly or not—to conduct that search. And once that happens, much of your legal protection is gone.

Continue reading

by

Understanding Your Rights After an Arrest in Illinois

Being arrested is one of the most frightening experiences a person can face. Whether it happens on the street in Bronzeville, during a traffic stop in Rogers Park, or as part of a federal investigation downtown, the fear and confusion are immediate—and one of the first questions people ask is, “How long can the police keep me here without charging me?”

As a longtime Chicago criminal defense lawyer and federal defense attorney, I’ve seen this question come up hundreds of times. The truth is that Illinois law, federal law, and constitutional protections work together to limit how long you can be held without formal charges. But those rules only help you if you understand them—and if you have legal counsel to enforce them.

Continue reading

by

Why the Bond Hearing Is the First Test in Any Criminal Case

Most people don’t realize how fast things move after an arrest in Chicago. One minute, someone is in the back of a squad car. The next, they’re standing before a judge while a prosecutor reads through their charges. What happens in those first 24 to 48 hours can determine whether someone goes home—or gets stuck in jail for weeks or months while the case moves through the system.

The bond hearing is not just a formality. It’s a critical step in the Illinois criminal justice process, and the outcome can influence everything that follows.

Continue reading

by

Why You Should Be Careful Before Talking to Police in DuPage County

If a DuPage County police officer, sheriff’s deputy, or detective reaches out and wants to question you about an incident, load your next steps with caution and understanding. Law enforcement officers in DuPage County—whether from Wheaton, Naperville, Downers Grove, or anywhere within the county—have one overriding goal when they approach someone: gather information that can be used to support a possible arrest or criminal charge. As a DuPage County criminal defense lawyer with decades of experience defending people accused of state and federal crimes, I can tell you that answering questions without proper legal protection can be the most damaging mistake you make.

In Illinois, crimes are classified as either misdemeanors or felonies. Misdemeanors include offenses like simple battery, disorderly conduct, DUI without aggravating factors, retail theft below a certain threshold, or cannabis possession. Felonies are more serious and include drug trafficking, felony theft, aggravated assault, weapons violations, and financial crimes. Whether the offense is a misdemeanor or a felony, what you say to police can influence whether charges are filed at all and what level they reach.

Continue reading

by

Can Chicago Police Use a Drug Dog After You Refuse a Search?

Understanding Your Rights When Refusing a Search in Chicago

I’ve represented clients in every part of Chicago—from Rogers Park to Roseland—who thought that refusing a police search would protect them. They assumed that once they said “no,” the police had to let them go. Then a K‑9 unit showed up. Suddenly, their car was being searched anyway.

Continue reading

by

Police K‑9 Delays and Your Rights During Chicago Traffic Stops

If you were pulled over in Chicago and the officer kept you waiting on the roadside while calling in a drug-sniffing dog, you probably asked yourself the same question many of my clients ask me: “Can they really hold me this long without charging me?” As a Chicago criminal defense lawyer who has fought hundreds of traffic stop cases, I can tell you this: if police held you longer than necessary without clear legal justification, they may have violated your constitutional rights.

Dog sniffs during traffic stops have become a common tactic used by police to escalate minor infractions into felony charges. Whether you were stopped in Garfield Ridge, Lincoln Park, or on I-90 near the city limits, the basic facts of the case often look the same: the officer approaches your vehicle, says it’s a routine traffic stop, checks your license, then calls in a K‑9 unit and keeps you waiting—hoping for a positive dog alert to justify a search.

Continue reading
Contact Information
Chicago Office
70 W Madison St
#1450
Chicago, IL 60602
Phone: (312) 560-7100
DuPage Office
140 Butterfield Rd
#1500
Oakbrook Terrace, IL 60181
Skokie Office
5250 Old Orchard Rd
#300
Skokie, IL 60077

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Please do not include any confidential or sensitive information in a contact form, text message, or voicemail. The contact form sends information by non-encrypted email, which is not secure. Submitting a contact form, sending a text message, making a phone call, or leaving a voicemail does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Copyright © 2026, Law Offices of David L. Freidberg, P.C.
JUSTIA Law Firm Blog Design