Chicago Criminal Lawyer Blog
When a Second Mistake Can Cost You Everything in Chicago
In a city as large and active as Chicago, the pressure of daily life often leads people to make split-second decisions that change their future. A new DUI charge while on probation is one of those moments that can send shockwaves through your life. I’ve represented hundreds of Chicago residents who made an error in judgment, only to discover that the justice system is far less forgiving when you’re already serving probation.
Probation is a privilege—an opportunity the judge gives instead of jail time under 730 ILCS 5/5-6-2. It allows you to live and work in your community while following strict conditions. But a single new arrest, even before conviction, can trigger a violation hearing. In Cook County, probation officers are quick to report arrests, and judges have broad discretion to revoke probation if they believe you broke the law or failed to follow the rules.
If the new charge is driving under the influence under 625 ILCS 5/11-501, your situation becomes even more complicated. The state views DUI offenses as a public safety risk, and prosecutors will push aggressively for penalties. That means you’re fighting two battles—one for the new DUI and another for your existing probation.
How the Two Cases Interact
Most people don’t realize that probation violations and new criminal cases proceed separately. A DUI charge triggers a new case in the criminal division of the Cook County Circuit Court. At the same time, your probation judge receives notice of your arrest and schedules a violation hearing. These hearings do not require proof “beyond a reasonable doubt.” Instead, the standard is merely a “preponderance of the evidence,” meaning it’s more likely than not that you violated your conditions.
For this reason, even if your DUI case is still pending or eventually dismissed, the judge can still revoke your probation based on the same arrest. The outcome depends on how both cases are managed and how well your lawyer coordinates your defense. Without experienced legal representation, you risk serving the original sentence behind bars—plus whatever penalties come from the new DUI.
A skilled Chicago criminal defense lawyer can often request that your probation violation hearing be delayed until the DUI case is resolved. This strategy prevents self-incrimination and keeps the state from using testimony or evidence against you in both matters.
The Criminal Process After a DUI Arrest
In Chicago, DUI arrests often begin with a routine stop on Lake Shore Drive, the Eisenhower Expressway, or a neighborhood street in Wrigleyville or Bronzeville. Officers look for signs such as erratic driving, speeding, or equipment violations. Once stopped, they may ask you to perform field sobriety tests or submit to a breath test.
If the officer believes you’re under the influence, you’ll be taken into custody. You’ll receive a Notice of Statutory Summary Suspension under 625 ILCS 5/11-501.1, meaning your license will be suspended regardless of the outcome of your case unless you file a petition to rescind within 90 days.
After booking, you’ll appear for a bond hearing before a judge, typically at 26th and California or the Daley Center. Because you’re on probation, the court may impose stricter conditions or deny release altogether. Your probation officer will also be notified, and a violation hearing date will be set.
Each of these steps carries risks. For example, any statement you make to police or probation officers can later be used against you. Your attorney must immediately step in to control the flow of information and ensure your constitutional rights remain intact.
The Investigation and Evidence in DUI and Probation Cases
The state’s evidence usually includes police dashcam or bodycam footage, field sobriety test results, breath or blood alcohol tests, and officer reports. Prosecutors may also subpoena witness statements or surveillance footage from local businesses.
For a probation violation, evidence can include police arrest records, probation reports, and even informal statements. Unlike a criminal trial, these hearings allow hearsay evidence and don’t require lab confirmation of alcohol content. This is why a defense attorney’s ability to scrutinize every piece of evidence becomes vital.
At my firm, we carefully evaluate every aspect of the stop—whether the officer had probable cause, whether tests were properly administered, and whether the equipment used was certified under Illinois law. In many cases, inconsistencies or procedural violations can lead to dismissal or a reduced charge.
A Realistic Example from Chicago
A client living in Uptown was on probation for a Class A misdemeanor retail theft case. Late one night, he was stopped for speeding on North Clark Street. Officers claimed he smelled of alcohol, though he passed most of the field tests. He refused the breath test and was charged with DUI. Within days, his probation officer filed a violation report.
We approached his defense in two stages. First, we challenged the DUI stop itself, proving through video evidence that his driving pattern did not justify a stop. Second, we requested the probation court to delay the hearing until the DUI case concluded. After a series of hearings, the DUI was dismissed due to lack of probable cause. We then moved to have the probation violation withdrawn. The client avoided jail entirely.
This example shows how timing, evidence, and an aggressive defense can mean the difference between freedom and incarceration.
Possible Penalties and Consequences
If you’re convicted of DUI while on probation, the consequences multiply. The probation court can revoke your probation, impose the original sentence, and the DUI court can hand down new penalties.
A first-time DUI is punishable by up to one year in jail, fines up to $2,500, and license suspension. But if this is your second offense or involves aggravating factors—such as an accident, a child passenger, or a suspended license—the charge may be upgraded to Aggravated DUI under 625 ILCS 5/11-501(d). That’s a felony punishable by one to twelve years in prison, depending on the circumstances.
Even if jail time is avoided, the fallout can include mandatory treatment, community service, costly interlock devices, and a permanent criminal record that affects employment and housing. Judges are often less sympathetic when you’re already on probation, making a strong defense essential.
Legal Defenses That May Apply
Every case is unique, but common defenses in these cases include:
-
The officer lacked legal cause for the traffic stop or arrest.
-
The field sobriety tests were administered improperly or under poor conditions.
-
The breath or blood testing equipment was defective or not certified.
-
The probation officer relied on unverified or unreliable information.
-
The arrest does not prove a violation because there’s no conviction.
Sometimes, we pursue negotiation-based strategies, such as treatment programs, probation modification, or deferred prosecution. The goal is always the same—protect your record, preserve your freedom, and prevent unnecessary penalties.
The Importance of an Experienced Chicago Criminal Defense Lawyer
When you’re balancing a new DUI charge and an existing probation case, one misstep can undo everything you’ve built. Having a knowledgeable defense attorney is not optional—it’s essential. I handle both cases simultaneously, ensuring that no statements or evidence harm your position in either court.
Our firm regularly represents clients in Cook County, DuPage County, Will County, and Lake County, appearing before judges who know our reputation for thorough, strategic defense. We negotiate aggressively with prosecutors and probation officers, often achieving outcomes that protect our clients’ freedom and future opportunities.
Chicago DUI Defense FAQs
What happens first—the probation hearing or the DUI case?
The court usually schedules the probation violation hearing shortly after the DUI arrest. However, your lawyer can request that it be postponed until the DUI case is resolved to avoid self-incrimination and inconsistent rulings.
Can I be found in violation of probation even if my DUI case is dismissed?
Yes. The burden of proof in a violation hearing is lower. The judge only needs to believe it’s more likely than not that you violated your conditions. That’s why having a lawyer present arguments and evidence is crucial.
Is a new DUI while on probation considered a felony automatically?
Not always. The classification depends on factors such as prior convictions, injuries, or license status. A standard first-time DUI is a misdemeanor, but repeat or aggravated cases can be felonies.
Can I get probation again for the new DUI?
It depends on your prior record and the facts of your case. Courts may be reluctant to offer probation twice, but a skilled attorney can negotiate alternatives like conditional discharge or work-release programs.
Will my probation officer be in court for the DUI case?
Your probation officer will likely attend the violation hearing and submit reports but is not involved in the DUI prosecution. However, anything you say to your officer can be used in both cases.
Can the court revoke my driver’s license immediately?
License suspension under the implied consent law happens administratively. Your attorney must file a petition to rescind the suspension within 90 days to challenge it.
What can a Chicago DUI lawyer actually do for me?
A qualified attorney investigates the stop, challenges tests, negotiates plea options, and protects your rights. They also coordinate with the probation court to reduce penalties or prevent revocation.
Why should I hire The Law Offices of David L. Freidberg?
Because experience matters. With decades of practice in Cook County courts, our firm understands how to manage complex cases involving probation violations and DUI charges. We provide round-the-clock representation, transparent communication, and proven results.
When You Need a Fighter, Call Us!
If you were arrested in Chicago, protect your future by contacting The Law Offices of David L. Freidberg. We have decades of experience handling criminal, DUI, and traffic cases in Illinois. Our firm is available 24/7 to provide the legal defense you deserve.
Contact us today at (312) 560-7100 or toll-free at (800) 803-1442 for a free consultation. We’re available 24/7 to serve clients throughout Illinois, Cook County, DuPage County, Will County, and Lake County.
