Why More Drivers Are Facing DUI Charges Without Drinking
On any given day, Chicago’s streets—from the historic corridors of Pilsen to the high-traffic stretches of the Dan Ryan Expressway—are packed with cars, buses, bikes, and pedestrians. Police patrols are constant, and DUI enforcement is a high priority. What surprises many drivers is that a DUI arrest can happen without a single sip of alcohol. In Illinois, legal prescription medication can lead to the same criminal charges as alcohol if an officer believes your driving ability is impaired.
Illinois’s DUI statute, 625 ILCS 5/11-501, makes it a crime to drive or be in actual physical control of a vehicle while under the influence of any drug—including medication prescribed by a physician—if it renders you incapable of driving safely. The focus is on impairment, not whether the drug was lawfully prescribed.
That means taking a prescribed sleep aid before bed and then driving too early the next morning, using pain medication after surgery, or even combining prescriptions with over-the-counter medication can create enough suspicion for a traffic stop, field sobriety testing, and arrest.
From Traffic Stop to Arrest: How These Cases Begin
A prescription drug DUI case in Chicago often starts with an officer noticing something unusual about your driving—delayed starts at green lights in River North, weaving slightly in Bronzeville, or stopping too far from the intersection in Jefferson Park. Even subtle behavior can be enough for a lawful stop.
Once pulled over, the officer will look for physical signs of impairment: sluggish responses, unfocused eyes, or trouble finding documents. They may ask whether you’ve been drinking, and if you say no but mention medication, that can trigger a deeper investigation. Field sobriety tests may follow, and if the officer is trained as a Drug Recognition Expert (DRE), they will assess you for signs linked to specific categories of drugs.
If the officer believes there is probable cause, you will be arrested and transported for chemical testing. Because most prescription medications cannot be detected with a roadside breath test, police will request blood or urine testing, which is covered under Illinois’s implied consent statute (625 ILCS 5/11-501.1). Refusing the test can result in an automatic license suspension, even if you are later acquitted.
The Criminal Case Process in Illinois
Once you are charged, the case proceeds in the county where the arrest occurred—most often Cook County for Chicago residents, but possibly DuPage, Will, or Lake counties if you were stopped in the suburbs.
The stages include:
-
Arraignment: You appear in court, are informed of the charges, and enter a plea.
-
Pretrial proceedings: Your attorney requests and reviews discovery, files motions to suppress evidence, and may negotiate with prosecutors.
-
Trial: If no agreement is reached, the case is decided by a judge or jury.
-
Sentencing: If convicted, the court imposes penalties.
Every stage is an opportunity for a defense attorney to protect your rights, challenge evidence, and push for dismissal or reduction of charges.
Penalties for Prescription Drug DUI
Illinois imposes the same sentencing structure for prescription drug DUIs as for alcohol-based cases. A first-time offense without aggravating factors is a Class A misdemeanor with potential penalties of up to one year in jail, a $2,500 fine, and a driver’s license suspension.
Aggravating factors—such as prior DUI convictions, an accident causing serious injury or death, or having a child under 16 in the vehicle—can elevate the charge to a felony. A Class 4 felony carries 1–3 years in prison, a Class 2 felonycarries 3–7 years, and more serious charges can result in even longer sentences.
Beyond criminal penalties, a conviction creates long-term consequences:
-
Permanent criminal record (no expungement or sealing in Illinois)
-
Higher insurance premiums
-
Loss of certain professional licenses
-
Potential employment and housing difficulties
Evidence Law Enforcement Relies On
Prosecutors in prescription drug DUI cases build their arguments using a combination of scientific testing and observational evidence. This often includes:
-
Officer testimony about your behavior and driving
-
Field sobriety test performance
-
Blood or urine toxicology results
-
Expert witness testimony about the effects of the drug in question
-
Video evidence from dashcams or body-worn cameras
-
Pharmacy records confirming the prescription
Challenging this evidence requires both legal and scientific knowledge—something that an experienced DUI defense attorney can bring to your case.
Fictional Example Case: A West Loop Arrest
Imagine a driver in Chicago’s West Loop heading home from work in the early evening. They recently started a new prescription for anxiety, which their doctor assured them was safe. At a red light, the driver’s car rolls forward slightly before the light changes, catching the attention of a nearby officer.
During the stop, the officer notices slow speech and slightly unfocused eyes. Field sobriety tests are administered, and while the driver completes some tasks correctly, others are shaky. A blood test later confirms the presence of the prescription drug.
The defense argues that the driver’s performance on the tests was within normal limits, the DRE evaluation was flawed, and the therapeutic drug level was not impairing. A pharmacology expert testifies in support. The judge finds insufficient proof of impairment and dismisses the charges.
Potential Legal Defenses
Defenses in these cases often focus on the absence of actual impairment or procedural mistakes by police:
-
Arguing the traffic stop lacked a lawful basis
-
Showing that medical conditions or fatigue caused symptoms mistaken for impairment
-
Demonstrating that field sobriety tests were improperly administered
-
Disputing the interpretation of toxicology results
-
Questioning the qualifications of the DRE or other witnesses
Because impairment is subjective, even small inconsistencies in the prosecution’s case can create reasonable doubt.
Why an Attorney Is Critical in Prescription Drug DUI Cases
Defending against a prescription drug DUI charge in Illinois requires a strong understanding of both criminal procedure and medical science. Without a skilled defense lawyer, you may miss opportunities to suppress evidence, challenge testing procedures, or negotiate reduced penalties.
An attorney can also guide you through the complexities of court appearances, motion practice, and trial preparation. This not only improves your chances in court but also reduces the stress of facing the criminal justice system.
The Law Offices of David L. Freidberg: Protecting Drivers in Chicago and Beyond
The Law Offices of David L. Freidberg has decades of experience defending clients in Chicago and throughout Cook, DuPage, Will, and Lake counties against DUI charges—including those involving prescription medication. The firm works with medical experts, challenges the state’s evidence, and fights for the best possible outcome in every case.
Contact us today at (312) 560-7100 or toll-free at (800) 803-1442 for a free consultation. We’re available 24/7 to serve clients throughout Illinois, Cook County, DuPage County, Will County, and Lake County.