What You Need to Know from a Chicago Defense Lawyer

It’s a common misunderstanding—many Chicago residents assume you can only be charged with DUI if you were pulled over while actively driving. But under Illinois law, that’s not always the case. If you’re found in your vehicle while intoxicated, even if the engine is off, the State can still charge you with driving under the influence if they believe you were in “actual physical control” of the car.

I’m a criminal defense attorney based in Chicago, and I’ve handled DUI cases across Cook County and beyond for decades. One of the more confusing types of DUI cases involves individuals who weren’t even seen driving. These cases often start with a parked car, a sleeping occupant, and an officer’s assumption. Maybe it happened in Lincoln Park, Bronzeville, or even on Lake Shore Drive, but the consequences can be the same—criminal charges, a suspended license, and a permanent record.

Let’s explore how these cases unfold, what the law says, and why hiring a Chicago DUI defense lawyer is essential when the police accuse you of DUI even if you weren’t driving.

---

Illinois DUI Law: Understanding “Actual Physical Control”

Illinois law defines DUI under 625 ILCS 5/11-501. The statute says that a person shall not drive or be in actual physical control of any vehicle while under the influence of alcohol, drugs, or a combination thereof. This “actual physical control” language has led to many controversial arrests and prosecutions, particularly in Chicago and its surrounding suburbs.

The courts in Illinois have held that physical control can include sitting in the driver’s seat with the keys in your possession, even if the engine is off. The prosecution doesn’t need video footage or eyewitness testimony that you were moving the car. They just need to convince a judge or jury that you had the ability to operate the vehicle while intoxicated.

In my experience, prosecutors in Chicago often push forward with these types of cases. Whether the car was parked legally or not, or whether the individual intended to sleep it off, doesn’t always matter to the State.

---

How These Arrests Happen in Chicago and Across Cook County

Arrests for DUI without observed driving often occur in parking lots, near bars, or along residential streets in places like Wicker Park, Uptown, or Jefferson Park. Sometimes a concerned citizen calls the police after seeing someone asleep in a car. Other times, officers are on patrol and initiate a “wellness check.”

Here’s how these arrests typically unfold:

• The officer knocks on the window and wakes the occupant.

• The officer claims to smell alcohol or observes signs of intoxication.

• The officer asks the individual to step out and perform field sobriety tests.

• The officer may ask where the keys are, and if they are nearby, that is used as evidence of control.

• A breath test may be requested. Refusing can trigger a license suspension under 625 ILCS 5/11-501.1.

The critical issue is not whether you were driving, but whether the police and prosecutor can make a case that you couldhave driven while intoxicated. That distinction may not feel fair—but it’s the legal landscape in Illinois.

---

Felony or Misdemeanor? Penalties if Convicted in Illinois

The baseline DUI charge is a Class A misdemeanor, which carries a potential sentence of up to one year in jail and fines up to $2,500. That’s serious enough, but it’s just the start. The consequences can escalate quickly depending on prior offenses or the circumstances of your case.

Under 625 ILCS 5/11-501(d), the charge may become a felony (Aggravated DUI) if:

• This is your third or subsequent offense

• You caused an accident with injury or death

• You had a child passenger under 16

• You were driving on a suspended or revoked license

Felony DUI in Illinois can be charged as a Class 4, Class 3, or even Class 2 felony, with prison terms ranging from 1 to 7 years or longer in enhanced cases. The felony label also means the charge will follow you for life, limiting your job opportunities, professional licensing, and firearm rights.

Even a first-time misdemeanor DUI can suspend your driver’s license and result in increased insurance rates, substance abuse classes, and permanent criminal records.

---

Fictional Case Example: Arrest in Albany Park Parking Lot

Let me illustrate with a fictional—but realistic—scenario. A young professional parks his car in a grocery store lot in Albany Park after a night out. He knows he shouldn’t drive and decides to sleep in the driver’s seat until he feels sober. The keys are in the center console. At around 4 a.m., police knock on his window. They claim he smells like alcohol, has glassy eyes, and slurred speech.

Even though the car never moved, the officer arrests him. The State charges him with DUI based on actual physical control. We challenged the case with a motion to suppress, arguing no probable cause existed to believe a crime had been committed. In this case, the court agreed that the arrest was unsupported by evidence of intent or active control. The charge was dismissed.

This type of result is not guaranteed, but it’s a clear example of why strong legal defense is vital from the start.

---

What Police and Prosecutors Rely On in These Cases

These types of DUI arrests rely heavily on circumstantial evidence. Since there’s no observed driving, law enforcement will try to build a case using:

• Location of the driver (were they behind the wheel?)

• Where the keys were located (in ignition, lap, or console)

• Whether the engine was on or warm

• Officer testimony about signs of impairment

• Statements made by the accused

• Physical signs like open containers in the vehicle

Body camera footage, dashcam video, and even local surveillance from nearby businesses in Chicago can come into play. These can either help or hurt your case depending on how they align with the officer’s report.

---

Illinois DUI Case Process: Step-by-Step Defense Strategy

Here’s what happens after your arrest and why legal representation matters at each point:

• Bond Hearing: We work to ensure you’re released on favorable terms.

• Formal Charges & Arraignment: The prosecutor files the complaint, and we respond strategically.

• Pretrial Motion Practice: We file motions to suppress unlawfully obtained evidence or statements.

• Discovery Review: We demand and examine every piece of police evidence, video, and testing logs.

• Negotiations: Depending on the strength of the case, we may push for reduced charges or supervision.

• Trial: If needed, we defend you before a judge or jury and raise reasonable doubt at every stage.

Without a seasoned attorney, you may miss opportunities to suppress key evidence or to challenge the credibility of the prosecution’s case.

---

Legal Defenses for Parked Vehicle DUI Charges

Some of the most effective defenses in these situations include:

• Lack of Physical Control: You were not in a position to drive; keys weren’t accessible, or you were in the back seat.

• Unlawful Arrest: If officers lacked probable cause, any evidence collected may be suppressed.

• Invalid Testing Procedures: Field tests were incorrectly performed or machines were not calibrated.

• No Proof of Impairment: Physical signs of fatigue or illness may have been mistaken for intoxication.

• Lack of Intent to Drive: If you were clearly attempting to sleep it off and not drive, that can support a defense.

Every case is different, but an experienced defense attorney knows how to raise these defenses through smart strategy and motion practice.

---

Why You Need an Attorney—And Why Sooner Is Better

Facing DUI charges in Illinois is not something you want to handle alone. When you weren’t even driving, the State’s case may be weak—but you’ll need a skilled criminal defense lawyer to expose that.

At The Law Offices of David L. Freidberg, I represent clients across Chicago and throughout Cook County, DuPage County, Will County, and Lake County. I’ve won dismissals, suppression motions, and reduced charges in precisely the kinds of cases where someone was charged despite not driving. I understand the nuances of Illinois DUI law, and I bring a strategic, aggressive approach to every defense.

---

Chicago DUI Defense FAQs: What Clients Ask About Parked-Car DUI Cases

Can I be charged with DUI if my car was parked legally in a private lot?
Yes, even in a private lot, Illinois law allows DUI charges if police believe you were in actual physical control. That’s why you need a lawyer to challenge their assumptions.

Will I lose my license even if I wasn’t driving?
Yes. Illinois law imposes automatic driver’s license suspensions for refusing or failing chemical tests—even if you weren’t driving at the time of arrest.

Can I beat a DUI if there’s no video showing me driving?
Possibly. Lack of video and no witnesses can work in your favor, especially if the only evidence is circumstantial. These cases often hinge on a strong legal defense.

How long does the DUI case process take in Chicago?
Misdemeanor cases typically last 3–6 months. Felony cases or those involving complex evidence can take longer. Your attorney will guide you at every step.

Is it better to sleep in my car than to drive drunk?
From a moral and safety perspective, yes. But legally, you could still be charged. That’s why knowing how to handle the situation and having a lawyer is critical.

Can I get court supervision if I’m charged but wasn’t driving?
Yes, court supervision may be available for first-time offenders. It avoids a conviction but still includes fees, classes, and possible monitoring. A defense lawyer can fight for this or seek dismissal altogether.

What happens if I plead guilty without a lawyer?
You could end up with a criminal conviction, license suspension, and no opportunity to raise defenses you didn’t know existed. Always consult an attorney before making any decision.